Canes Vs. Walkers - Pros & Cons of Each - MedPlus (2024)

FAQs

Canes Vs. Walkers - Pros & Cons of Each - MedPlus? ›

How do I know if I would benefit from using a cane or walker? If you have pain or weakness on one side of your body that makes it hard to walk or balance, a cane may be helpful. If you have poor balance or feel unsteady on your feet, a walker may give you more support.

How do I know if I would benefit from using a cane or walker? If you have pain or weakness on one side of your body that makes it hard to walk or balance, a cane may be helpful. If you have poor balance or feel unsteady on your feet, a walker may give you more support.

The difference between walking sticks and canes is their purpose. Walking sticks are used for stability and balance while walking on uneven terrain, while Walking canes are used for support and balance for those with mobility issues.

Lack of Proper Fit and Adjustability:

One of the most common issues with these gadgets is more accurate fit and adaptability. Each person has a unique height and body proportions, and using an improperly fitting product can cause discomfort, instability, and an increased risk of falling.

Canes provide stability on uneven or slippery surfaces and help seniors with balance issues when walking. The main con of using a cane is that it requires upper body strength. It may be difficult for seniors with limited mobility or those with certain medical conditions to use a cane.

So, my first factor in determining whether to recommend a cane is strength. Basically, if you're going to use a cane, you need to have enough strength to walk at least the distance you'll be using it to walk (household or community) a couple of times in a row securely. The second factor I consider is balance.

A cane can be helpful if you have minor problems with balance or stability, some weakness in your leg or trunk, an injury, or a pain. If you are elderly, using a single point cane may help you to walk more comfortably and safely and, in some cases, may make it easier for you to continue living independently.

“Generally I recommend walking sticks for anyone with joint pain,” Michael Fredericson, MD, professor of orthopaedic surgery at Stanford Health Care, told Verywell. “They also provide a better workout if used aggressively, improve balance issues, and provide support on uneven trails.”

Baby walkers give babies unnatural height and speed which increases the risk of injury, whilst also forcing walking before the baby may be developmentally ready. Read on to learn more about the dangers associated with baby walkers and why physiotherapists advise against using them.

Children in baby walkers can:

Roll down the stairs—which often causes broken bones and severe head injuries. This is how most children get hurt in baby walkers. Get burned—a child can reach higher in a walker.

What are the negatives of walkers? ›

According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, walkers do not help children to walk quickly, much less to achieve a good gait, because according to research, it prevents the child's muscles from developing properly, causing babies to walk sideways, avoiding natural movement when walking, preventing the mobility of ...

Some people may "self-treat" as canes are easily accessible and do not require a prescription before being purchased. This increases the risks of falls, especially in elderly patients. There is also a risk of musculoskeletal injuries or postural adaptations if individuals use / hold the assistive device incorrectly.

Walkers. These are the most stable walking aids because they have four legs. Walkers can be especially helpful for those with back and joint pain, because they shift weight off of joints. Walkers come with or without wheels, depending on what is easier and more comfortable for the user.

Single point canes can help with early balance problems. Four point or “quad” canes add more stability and help even more with balance.

A walker can make it easier to get around after surgery or after a bone break in your foot or leg. A walker also can help if you have balance problems, arthritis, leg weakness or leg instability. A walker allows you to keep weight off your feet and legs as you move.

Brisk walk

Suitable for people of all ages, a brisk walk can help you burn more calories, strengthen your muscles and bones, improve your cardiovascular system and lower your risk of chronic diseases. It is also great for people who want to prepare themselves for more challenging types of walking.