In recent weeks I’ve seen one too many bowls of rising bread dough covered with only a towel. While many of you (my mother included) rely on this as your go-to method (who can blame you, cookbooks even prescribe it), trust me that covering your dough with something better than a towel can pay big dividends for flavor and rise. Let me explain.
Why you should never cover rising bread dough with a towel
During the first rise in breadmaking, our goal is active fermentation. That’s why we carefully measure our yeast, pay attention to our water temperature, and even sometimes calculate desired dough temperatures. These steps support an even, healthy rate of fermentation, producing bready flavors and high-rising bakes. Good fermentation = great loaves.
Covering your dough correctly is a crucial step here. For best results, we want a non-porous, tight-fitting cover that will keep the dough from becoming too cool or developing a skin. And a towel doesn’t cut it: The porous material allows heat to escape, causing the dough to lose temperature. As the dough cools, fermentation grinds to a halt, resulting in sluggish dough with poor fermentation. (You may have read our Bread Coach piece on sluggish dough and resulting problems. Add towels to the list of things to avoid.) What’s more, the porous material that allows heat out also allows air in, drying out your dough and creating a skin that inhibits rising, shaping, and, eventually, baking. The result? Poorly fermented dough that bakes up as squat, dense bread.
To demonstrate the difference between a well-covered dough (anything that forms a non-porous, tight-fitting cover will work, such as a bowl coveror a tight-fitting lid) and a towel-covered dough, I mixed a double batch of our Classic Sandwich Bread. I placed half the dough (one loaf) into a bowl covered with a towel and the other half into a bowl with a bowl cover. I set them in the same location in my cool kitchen.
Over the course of the first rise, the dough in the towel-covered bowl dropped from 78˚F to 65˚F, while the bowl with the bowl cover on it only dropped to 74˚F. While it may seem like a small difference, that larger drop in temperature means that my towel-covered dough rises much more slowly, likely resulting in an underproofed loaf with a tight crumb and low overall volume.
Indeed, the two doughs looked like different mixes after the first rise. One was perfect — marshmallow-y and active — while the other was sluggish and dense.
The differences didn’t end there. When I dumped the doughs out for shaping, another problem appeared: a tight skin had formed on the surface of the towel-covered dough.
Martin Philip
That skin proved problematic during shaping: The dry patches on the outside didn't stretch or develop tension like my well-covered, elastic dough. The leathery sections ruptured and cracked. And further, the dry skin resisted sticking to the rest of the mass, leaving me with a cracked surface and a dough prone to bursting or unraveling rather than swelling evenly during proofing and baking. In contrast, the well-covered dough was set up for success. Its moist surface adhered to itself during shaping, setting up a good final rise and a beautiful shape.
And remember how the towel-covered dough was sluggish? The volume difference is clearly apparent during shaping, with one loaf sized like a well-fed twin and the other struggling to rise.
Martin Philip
Hopeful for some improvement during the final rise, I placed the two loaves in pans and set them in a warmer spot to encourage the towel-covered loaf towards a come-from-behind victory.
I stretched a bowl cover over one and used a towel for the other. I also extended the final rise, trying to give the sluggish dough a fighting chance. But, as with the first rise, the towel-covered loaf formed yet another skin. Argh!
After the bake, the story continued with the sluggish, skinned-over loaf and our nice, open-crumbed high-riser.
Martin Philip
So, what can you do? Do you need to buy bowl covers? That’s certainly an option. I use them to cover my hearth-baked loaves that rise in bannetons, as well as on bowls of rising dough. I also have a few 6-quart containers that are perfect for larger batches like our Pain de Campagne.
But you don’t necessarily have to buy anything. I often just grab a large pot lid and use that over a bowl of proofing dough. A sheet tray works too — just make sure the seal is tight enough to prevent any air movement. For especially large batches I often use a food-safe trash bag, placing the entire bowl of dough inside the bag. After a few uses I use it as a trash bag so it’s not wasted.
So cover those bowls, bakers, and get ready for the high-rising, tastier days ahead!
Put your bowl-covering knowledge to use with The Easiest Loaf of Bread You'll Ever Bake:
Cover photography by Martin Philip.
