How to Create a Party Menu [12 Easy Tips] - Play Party Plan (2024)

Planning the perfect party menu is easier than you think! These tips and tricks will help you figure out exactly what you should serve, when you should serve it, and how much you should serve!

One the questions I get asked the most is how do I make a party menu? So I’ve put together my tips for creating the ultimate party menu, no matter what the occasion. I’ve used these for planning a 50th birthday party, a bohemian bridal shower, a Halloween carnival, and more!

The one thing that is missing in this post are actual recipes! If you need those, these are my top party foods ever. They’re great for pretty much any occasion and work well in any setting, no matter what your answers are to my questions below!

How Do I Make a Party Menu

When you’re thinking about your party menu, think of the four T’s as you’re planning. If you think about these four T’s when planning your menu, you’ll be golden for any event!

1. Time
2. Theme
3. Type
4. Temp

Time

The first thing to consider is what time is your party? If it’s during a mealtime, you’ll need to either serve something that works as a meal or heavy enough appetizers or snacks that it can substitute for a meal. If it’s not during a mealtime, you can typically get away with less food.

The next question to ask is what time of day is your party? This will help determine what type of food to serve. If you’re hosting a breakfast party or a brunch, you may lean more towards things like blueberry muffins or one of these breakfast board ideas. On the flip side, if it’s a game night after dinner, you may just want to do some of your favorite desserts.

The third question to ask about time is how long is your party? If you’re hosting something longer where people will likely graze throughout the party, you’ll want to make sure that your menu is full of things that are good to stay out for long periods of time (or can be heated/chilled easily).

If it’s a shorter time period or if you’re doing a specific time just for eating, you can typically serve more finicky foods like an Oreo ice cream cake or cheese stuffed meatballs that should be eaten quickly after serving.

And the final time related question to ask is how much time will I have for food prep? This is an important one to think about because if you only have a few hours to cook right before the party, you may want to buy most of the food and just make a few simple dessert dips to round it out.

If you know you’ll have time the day before but not the day of, you’ll want to plan good make ahead foods like striped delight, homemade Chex Mix, and strawberry lemonade.

Type

The second thing to think about is what type of party or event are you planning. Are you hosting an adults only co*cktail party that requires fancier appetizers or are you hosting a family-friendly Halloween carnival where you want lots of cutesy Halloween treats.

Another question to ask is what type of food sensitivities or lifestyles do you need to be aware of when planning the menu? If it’s a small party with just a few people and someone has a peanut allergy, you may want to skip out on that peanut butter pie. If it’s a large party and you’re making quite a few things, I always recommend having options for people who are gluten free, dairy free, and nut free. Fruit, veggies, and charcuterie boards with lots of options are often a good choice.

Temp

The third thing to consider, and it’s a biggie, is the temperature. There are a few questions to ask yourself related to temperatures.

First, what will the temperature be of the venue you’re hosting in? Will it be indoor or outdoor? If you’re hosting something a backyard bbq and it’ll be a hot summer day, you’ll want to avoid things like lemon cupcakes that might have frosting that will melt off in the heat and will want to serve things to cool guests down like creamy lemonade. If it’s indoors with a climate you can control, you have a lot more flexibility with your menu.

Next, will you be able to control the temperature of the food? In other words, do you have a way to keep things chilled or keep things warm or does everything need to be tasty at room temperature? If you don’t want to deal with things like coolers and chafing dishes, you’ll want to plan a menu full of good at room temp dishes.

Lastly, as you’re planning the menu, ask yourself what temperature does your food need cooked at? This is especially important if you’re planning to serve food warm or want it relatively warm when gets are eating. If you’re hosting a Super Bowl Party and want to serve sticky chicken wings and taco dip with ground beef, do you have two ovens since they cook at different times?

Theme

Once you’ve determined the time for your party, you can move onto thinking about the theme and matching foods to your theme (if you have one) and color scheme.

If you do have a particular theme for the party, it’s fun to choose at least some food items that match your theme. If you’re doing a black and white party for instance, you’d want all black and white foods on your menu. If you’re doing an Disney birthday party, you would want Avengers themed foods.

If you don’t have a theme or the theme is a generic one like 28 is great, then you can think about your theme less. Or you can choose your own theme for the food such as the birthday guests favorite things.

Party Food Planning Final Thought

At the end of the day, you don’t want the food – the planning, preparation, or presentation – to stress you out so much that you can’t even enjoy the party. Keep it as simple as possible unless you’re someone that really wants to do something elaborate.

While good food can really elevate a party, it’s better to have a handful of knockout dishes that all work together to support your theme/party style than it is to have twenty different dishes that are just thrown together to have more food.

Party Food Planning FAQs

Delicious Party Food

Now that you know how to plan your party menu, it’s time to get to it! These are some of the best party foods out there!

• Best Mexican appetizers – a collection of the best Mexican appetizers for Taco Tuesday, Mexican fiestas, and any other taco or nacho themed party!
• Christmas appetizers – tons of easy to make Christmas appetizers perfect for any holiday party!
• Patriotic desserts – red, white, and blue desserts for any of the occasions that celebrate those colors!