Why the First Five Ingredients Matter in Dog Food (2024)

If you’ve ever walked down the dog food aisle of your local pet store, you’ve probably felt a little overwhelmed by all the beautiful packaging promising quality ingredients.

From cows grazing in fields, fish flying over beautiful rivers or an array of healthy vegetables –– everything looks great, but how do you know the ingredients match the marketing?

It may sound strange at first, but it’s actually important to read the back of your dog’s food label.

According to the FDA, food ingredients are listed in order of weight. Ingredients that are highest in quantity are listed first, followed by the remaining ingredients listed in descending order.

This means if your dog’s food claims to have tons of protein, but the first ingredient is a carbohydrate, it’s fair to question the claim.

Starting With Protein

The first five ingredients of your dog’s food should always start with protein. Dogs are omnivores, so they receive energy and nutrients from both plant and animal nutrients. But protein is essential to their muscle and tissue development, immune system health, energy, and healthy skin and nails.

Protein levels in your dog’s food can vary depending on your dog’s age, weight, breed, and if they are puppies or pregnant.

Complete proteins have the 10 essential amino acids dogs need for survival. According to the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AFFCO), dog food identified as “complete and balanced” maintains a minimum crude protein level.

Types of Protein and Amounts

For Adult Maintenance diets, the minimum level of crude protein required is 18%, and for Growth and Reproduction diets, the minimum level is 22% on a dry matter basis. Meaning, for a particular life stage, there’s a specific amount of protein your dog needs to meet the requirements of a “complete and balanced” diet.

Not all proteins are created equal. In high-protein dog food, whole proteins like poultry, beef, or chicken should be listed first.

Other proteins are also listed as the following:

  • Whole meats –– proteins that have not been mixed
  • Meals –– rendered whole meats often listed with the proteins name
  • Meat meals –– rendered whole meats listed without identifying a specific protein
  • By-product meals –– includes poultry and other meats, including organs

We wrote an entire breakdown of meals to help you better understand the difference.

Generally, you want to choose a dog food with whole meats and meals in the first ingredients to ensure your dog is eating the right amount of protein.

The Other Ingredients

When you’re reading the back of your dog’s food label, there are a few essential ingredients you should look out for:

  • Protein
  • Carbohydrates
  • Healthy fats
  • Vitamins and minerals

As we mentioned, the first five ingredients should start with protein, but your dog’s diet should not solely depend on protein. When you think of well-balanced nutrition for your pup, you can visualize it just like a human meal –– with healthy foods representing each major food group.

At a minimum, your dog’s food should have the ingredients mentioned above to be specified by AAFCO as “complete and balanced.”

Ingredients To Avoid In The First Five

Depending on your dog’s dietary restrictions, there are also ingredients you want to avoid in the first five ingredients of your dog’s food. Why? Because your fur friends’ health is a top priority! You want them to eat a wholesome diet that starts with essential nutrients so they can live long, happy lives.

Stay away from foods where the first five ingredients include carbohydrates, white flour, artificial colors, and by-products. Also, if there’s an ingredient your dog is sensitive to, it should not be in the first five ingredients.

Here’s an example:

Your dog doesn’t do well with yams, so you want a dog food formula with little to no yams. Make sure the label doesn’t include yams in the first five ingredients. Remember, ingredients listed towards the end of the ingredient list are less abundant than those at the beginning.

Redbarn’sDry Dog Foodis a great choice if you’re looking for protein-packed nutrition that starts with five high-qualityanimal proteins in the first five ingredients.

Available in both grain-free and whole grain, each recipe recreates your dog’s ancestral diet. Our grain-free formula is balanced with vegetables and nutrient-rich legumes, and our whole grain formula features barley, brown rice, oatmeal, sunflower oils, and flaxseed.

Looking for a topper that also functions as a full feed?

Redbarn’s Air Dried Dog Foodhas85% or morefish, chicken or beefin every bag. We’ve also blended each recipe with flaxseed, salmon oil, vitamins, and minerals. Best of all? It’s oven-roasted and minimally processed to retain the meat’s nutrition.

No matter what option you choose, the key takeaway is to check out the first five ingredients in your dog’s food. The first five ingredients are the most important part of your dog’s food.

Why the First Five Ingredients Matter in Dog Food (2024)

FAQs

Why the First Five Ingredients Matter in Dog Food? ›

The top five ingredients in dog food should consist of a balance of protein, carbohydrates, healthy fats and fatty acids, fiber, and essential vitamins and minerals. First of all, a high-quality source of animal protein, such as fish, beef, or deboned chicken, should be the main ingredient.

Is answers a good dog food? ›

Is Answers A Good Dog Food? Overall, Answers dog food is considered a low risk food with high quality ingredients, and all recipes scoring 9.5/10.

Why does the first ingredient matter? ›

Ingredients are listed on products in descending order by weight so that the first ingredient listed is always present in the largest amount and can be useful when comparing products.

Do dog food ingredients matter? ›

While the ingredient list might not tell you the quality of the ingredients, it does tell you what's in the food. This is especially important for dogs with special dietary needs or allergies. It's also useful for owners who wish to feed their dogs specific sources of fiber, protein, and carbohydrates.

What dog food to stay away from? ›

10 Dog Food Brands to Avoid
  • 10 Dog Food Brands to Avoid. Your pup's presence is a gift in and of itself. ...
  • IAMS. ...
  • Purina. ...
  • Alpo. ...
  • Kal Kan. ...
  • Cesar. ...
  • Kibbles 'n Bits. ...
  • Beneful.
Jun 15, 2024

What do vets say is the best dog food? ›

Royal Canin is a favorite dog food brand among our experts for its peer-reviewed research and well-regarded reputation among pet parents and veterinarians. Both NBC Select updates editor Mili Godio and manager of editorial operations Shari Uyehara are fans of Royal Canin, too.

How can you tell if dog food is high quality? ›

Look for: Meat and fat products that are identified by species, such as “deboned salmon meal.” If the species is not identified (i.e., ingredients include “meat”, “poultry” or “fish” products) then you can't be sure of the quality. Foods with meat as the first ingredient(s), and starches lower on the list.

Is premium dog food really better? ›

Premium dog food is held to the same minimum standards for nutrition as cheap dog food. But if it doesn't meet AAFCO standards, it's best to keep shopping. It's also worth doing a little digging into the brand.

What is the 5 ingredient rule? ›

Stick to the 5 ingredient rule: Choose foods with less than 5 ingredients and all things you recognize and know are real food, such as tomatoes, water, or salt. Or if there are more than 5, make sure they're all food or spices. Buy only packaged foods with ingredients you can pronounce or recognize.

What should top 3 ingredients be in dog food? ›

When you're reading the back of your dog's food label, there are a few essential ingredients you should look out for: Protein. Carbohydrates. Healthy fats.

What is the main ingredient in dry dog food? ›

Common Dog Food Ingredients

Cereals, which are basic carbohydrates like grain, rice bran, and beet pulp. Vegetables. Fish, which provide both protein and calcium. Fats and oils, a source for vitamins, as well as the energy that dogs need to survive.

What should the first five ingredients be in dog food? ›

The top five ingredients in dog food should consist of a balance of protein, carbohydrates, healthy fats and fatty acids, fiber, and essential vitamins and minerals. First of all, a high-quality source of animal protein, such as fish, beef, or deboned chicken, should be the main ingredient.

What is the best food to feed a dog? ›

Feeding dogs a diet made with natural, real ingredients, such as beef, chicken, lamb, peas, spinach, carrots, and blueberries, can do wonders for their overall well-being — promoting heart health, increasing energy level, making coats shiny and breath smell better, improving eyesight, and even impacting a dog's stool.

What is the ideal composition of dog food? ›

Scientific research has shown that an adult dog's daily diet can contain up to 50% carbohydrates by weight, including 2.5–4.5% from fiber. A minimum of approximately 5.5% of the diet should come from fats and 10% from protein. Petfood labels do not generally list amounts of essential nutrients in grams.

What are the best ingredients to put in homemade dog food? ›

Good homemade food for healthy dogs includes all the vitamins, calcium, proteins and minerals your pet needs to stay healthy. You can add ground beef, chicken, lamb or venison, as well as vegetables, such as zucchini, carrots, parsnips, beets, yams, butternut squash, and sweet potatoes.

What should the second ingredient in dog food be? ›

When choosing a pet food, the most important thing to do is to read the ingredients list. Quality and nutritious foods for both dogs and cats should have a named animal protein (like chicken, salmon, or lamb) or animal meal (like chicken meal or lamb meal) as at least the first and second ingredient.

What are the proper ratios for homemade dog food? ›

Your dog food should take into consideration the following ratio of 40% protein, 50% vegetables, and 10% starch.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Terrell Hackett

Last Updated:

Views: 6276

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Terrell Hackett

Birthday: 1992-03-17

Address: Suite 453 459 Gibson Squares, East Adriane, AK 71925-5692

Phone: +21811810803470

Job: Chief Representative

Hobby: Board games, Rock climbing, Ghost hunting, Origami, Kabaddi, Mushroom hunting, Gaming

Introduction: My name is Terrell Hackett, I am a gleaming, brainy, courageous, helpful, healthy, cooperative, graceful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.